Two publications reviewed Nintendo's remake of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for the Nintendo Switch 2, and both critics praised the game while describing different reactions to playing it.
NPR's review, written by James Perkins Mastromarino, said the remake enshrines the game's place in the gaming canon for generations to come. The headline called the game "superb, streamlined and safe." According to the review, the remake has stupendous production values, yet it left the reviewer feeling oddly bereft.
The Guardian's review, written by Keza MacDonald, described the project as an ambitious remake that transforms Zelda into a modern masterpiece. According to the review, the game is clearer, easier to navigate and more beautiful to look at, with playful musical touches, and its melancholy remains. The review opened by describing the worry of returning to a formative piece of art from one's childhood.
Both reviews describe the remake as polished. NPR cited its production values and streamlined design, while The Guardian cited its clearer navigation and improved visuals. The reviews differ on the emotional effect. NPR said the game left its reviewer bereft, while The Guardian's headline described the remake as a dream come true.
This report is based on the headlines and published summaries of the two reviews.
Sources: NPR: Review: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake is superb, streamlined and safe; The Guardian: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time review - a dream come true.