A federal appeals court ruled on Friday that a $1.7 trillion government funding bill passed by Congress in 2022 under former President Biden was unconstitutional, according to The Hill's report. The bill passed through a pandemic-era rule that allowed lawmakers to vote by proxy, the outlet reported.
The ruling came from the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which is based in New Orleans. The Hill reported that the court voted 9-8 and stated that "voting by proxy went against the Constitution’s Quorum." The summary does not reproduce the full ruling.
The Hill's summary ends mid-sentence at that point, so the remainder of the court's reasoning is not included in the material used for this story. The available text does not say how individual judges voted or what the decision means for the funding bill going forward.
The Hill's headline describes the bill as Biden-era, a label the summary itself does not explain. The only numerical details in the material are the $1.7 trillion bill amount and the 9-8 vote count. The Hill's summary gives no other amounts, dates, or names beyond the author and the court.
Ryan Mancini is the author of the report, which The Hill published on November 22, 2026. This account rests on that single outlet and on the summary provided for it, and no other reporting on the ruling was included in the material used here.
The complete reasoning behind the decision is in The Hill's original report. Nothing in the available material indicates whether other courts or outlets have addressed the same bill or rule.
Sources: The Hill: $1.7T Biden-era government funding bill found unconstitutional, appeals court rules.